Grammarly vs. Turnitin AI
Navigating Academic Integrity in the Age of AI

The Grammarly Dilemma Is Using Grammarly Considered Plagiarism?

Many students utilize tools like Grammarly Premium for grammar and clarity enhancements. However, the question arises: Does using Grammarly's 'clarity function' or other features constitute academic misconduct or plagiarism? This article delves into the nuances of using such tools in academic writing.

The original Reddit thread from r/AskProfessors highlights the core concern: whether rephrasing suggestions from Grammarly's 'clarity' function could trigger plagiarism detection software such as Turnitin's AI detection tools. The consensus is that using Grammarly, in most instances, is acceptable and even encouraged, but full AI writing tools are not. This distinction is crucial.

Turnitin AI Detection How AI Detection Works and What It Means for You

Turnitin AI and similar tools are designed to identify text generated by artificial intelligence. These tools look for patterns and characteristics unique to AI-generated content. But, does Grammarly trigger them? The answer is generally no.

Experts suggest that Grammarly's suggestions, while helpful, don't typically contain the hallmarks of AI-generated text. This is because the final decisions on word choice and phrasing rest with the student. Unlike writing an essay with ChatGPT, the user maintains control over the content.

“

Using something like ChatGPT is totally different, IMO, and writes the thing for you whole cloth.

zorandzam

Best Practices Using Grammarly Ethically and Effectively

To use Grammarly responsibly, consider these guidelines:

1. Review and Understand Suggestions: Don't blindly accept suggestions. Evaluate each one critically.

2. Maintain Original Voice: Ensure your writing maintains your unique voice and style.

3. Seek Clarification from Instructors: If unsure about the policies, always clarify with your professor or institution.

4. Avoid Over-Reliance: Grammarly is a tool to aid in clarity, not a substitute for critical thinking or original thought.

“

This likely depends on your institution, and potentially even individual professor's policies.

PurrPrinThom

Institutional Policies Understanding Your Institution's Stance on AI Tools

Policies vary widely. Some institutions may explicitly allow Grammarly, while others may consider certain uses a form of academic misconduct. PurrPrinThom’s comment in the Reddit thread stresses the importance of understanding your institution's policies.

It is essential to know your institution’s policy and if your professor allows the use of such tools. If unsure, it is always best to seek clarification from the instructor.